Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Entertainment
   Butch Vig says Kurt Cobain's solo album was "all in his head." But not for long

29 Apr 2012 04:34 AM   |   4207 clicks   |   Winnipeg Sun
Add Comment
Showing 1-50 of 61 comments
Refresh Page 2
germ78     
I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

28 Apr 2012 11:40 PM
Reply
Mentat    [TotalFark]  
germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

It was worth a shot.

28 Apr 2012 11:47 PM
Reply
Adolf Oliver Nipples    [TotalFark]  
germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Number one with a bullet, with widespread acclaim!

28 Apr 2012 11:48 PM
Reply
GungFu     
Ah, the album he self released.

29 Apr 2012 04:50 AM
Reply
James Scameron     
did it have the song "Scrape Me" on it?

29 Apr 2012 04:53 AM
Reply
LewDux     
I blame Yoko Ono

29 Apr 2012 04:56 AM
Reply
LonMead     

29 Apr 2012 05:05 AM
Reply
twiztedjustin     
So the guy that made their album in 1991 would know what Cobain did in 1994. Excellent article!

I'd be interested to hear any new material, but if it isn't just Cobain on an acoustic guitar solo or the trio of guys playing it probably isn't as good as what I've already heard.

29 Apr 2012 05:10 AM
Reply
flamingboar     
In before the "omg nirvana sucks and are over rated and this one band I like is sooooooo much better because I said so!"

29 Apr 2012 05:10 AM
Reply
JonPace     
flamingboar: omg nirvana sucks and are over rated

29 Apr 2012 05:44 AM
Reply
LowbrowDeluxe     
germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Mentat: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

It was worth a shot.


Adolf Oliver Nipples: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Number one with a bullet, with widespread acclaim!


GungFu: Ah, the album he self released.

Proving yet again why I love Fark.

29 Apr 2012 05:48 AM
Reply
Passive Aggressive Larry     
In all seriousness, I'd be very interested to hear what such an album would have sounded like. Wasn't Cobain supposed to meet up with Michael Stipe shortly before he killed himself and work around with some material? Stipe might have been producing it or something. I forget what I saw this on, or read it in, but apparently Cobain was such a fan of Automatic For the People, that he wanted to take Nirvana in a similar type of more mellow and introspective songwriting direction, and you can see a bit of it with how they approached their MTV Unplugged performance.

29 Apr 2012 06:33 AM
Reply
jiaxiaobo     
"Cobain was more concerned with his rocker wife Courtney Love's career"

ugh, getting together with her, talk about career suicide

29 Apr 2012 07:53 AM
Reply
Ed Finnerty     
On an unrelated note, "Butch Vag" would be a great name for a band.

29 Apr 2012 08:09 AM
Reply
BumpInTheNight     
LowbrowDeluxe: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Mentat: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

It was worth a shot.

Adolf Oliver Nipples: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Number one with a bullet, with widespread acclaim!

GungFu: Ah, the album he self released.

Proving yet again why I love Fark.


I agree, threads like these are such a blast!

29 Apr 2012 08:10 AM
Reply
BroVinny     
TOO SOON

/I lol'ed

29 Apr 2012 08:49 AM
Reply
WhyteRaven74     
twiztedjustin: So the guy that made their album in 1991 would know what Cobain did in 1994. Excellent article!

Vig was always in touch with Cobain and became really good friends with Grohl, so he'd know what was going on.

29 Apr 2012 08:49 AM
Reply
SharkTrager     
LonMead: A lot of stuff Vig did after that was Garbage.

Saw Garbage last weekend. They still have it.

29 Apr 2012 10:22 AM
Reply
Midnight Rambler     
Passive Aggressive Larry: Cobain was such a fan of Automatic For the People

Yep. If I recall, Cobain had an R.E.M. CD in his player when they found his body.

29 Apr 2012 10:28 AM
Reply
Tron-tonian     
If there were recordings, Courtney would have released them long ago to pay for a fix, then sold the rights for another one.

29 Apr 2012 11:14 AM
Reply
El_Swino     
Now it's all over his wall and ceiling.

29 Apr 2012 11:59 AM
Reply
LectertheChef     
Doubt there's some lost recordings thing floating around out there. I do remember shortly after Mark Sandman died, a ton of stuff he'd recorded for just whatever that was never released was put out. But Cobain was nowhere as prolific a songwriter as Sandman, nor as talented. Cobain seemed more interested in trying to convince everyone he hadn't sold out than he was in actually making music.

29 Apr 2012 12:29 PM
Reply
The My Little Pony Killer     
Do not want. That stuff, if it exists, went unreleased for a reason. Stop suckling off his corpse and find your own gig already.

29 Apr 2012 12:37 PM
Reply
Your Average Witty Fark User     
Passive Aggressive Larry: Wasn't Cobain supposed to meet up with Michael Stipe shortly before he killed himself

That's awfully presumptuous. Tom Grant at least raises some very valid questions that have gone unanswered.

29 Apr 2012 01:02 PM
Reply
ThatBillmanGuy     
SharkTrager: LonMead: A lot of stuff Vig did after that was Garbage.

Saw Garbage last weekend. They still have it.


Saw them in Vegas last weekend myself. They still rock. But apparently, either Butch or Duke has had a death in the family right after that, so they've been cancelling every show since then.

29 Apr 2012 02:03 PM
Reply
zvoidx     
Your Average Witty Fark User: Passive Aggressive Larry: Wasn't Cobain supposed to meet up with Michael Stipe shortly before he killed himself

That's awfully presumptuous. Tom Grant at least raises some very valid questions that have gone unanswered.


And to people who would doubt a motive; Courtney Love has already plowed through half a billion dollars since 1994.

29 Apr 2012 02:10 PM
Reply
SharkTrager     
ThatBillmanGuy: SharkTrager: LonMead: A lot of stuff Vig did after that was Garbage.

Saw Garbage last weekend. They still have it.

Saw them in Vegas last weekend myself. They still rock. But apparently, either Butch or Duke has had a death in the family right after that, so they've been cancelling every show since then.


Ours was, for a reason I do not know, the only one in that stretch not cancelled.

And I am so in love with Shirley Manson it's not even funny.

29 Apr 2012 02:46 PM
Reply
Mentat    [TotalFark]  
img39.imageshack.us

29 Apr 2012 03:04 PM
Reply
AcneVulgaris     
Kurt just threw it at the wall to see if it would stick.

29 Apr 2012 03:11 PM
Reply
BumpInTheNight     
AcneVulgaris: Kurt just threw it at the wall to see if it would stick.

Ahh yes, the ol shotgun approach.

29 Apr 2012 03:28 PM
Reply
Your Average Witty Fark User     
zvoidx: Your Average Witty Fark User: Passive Aggressive Larry: Wasn't Cobain supposed to meet up with Michael Stipe shortly before he killed himself

That's awfully presumptuous. Tom Grant at least raises some very valid questions that have gone unanswered.

And to people who would doubt a motive; Courtney Love has already plowed through half a billion dollars since 1994.


At the time, Kurt had just turned down a VERY lucrative offer from Lollapalooza, Nirvana was on the brink of breaking up, and Kurt was about to walk away from it all. Courtney's cash cow was going to dry up. To her, he was worth way, way more dead than alive.

It pisses me off that more investigation hasn't been done into the questions Tom Grant raises. It's awfully, awfully troubling that he's raised these questions, and people close to the case have coincidentally turned up dead. I'm not saying she 100% is behind it, but I think it deserves investigation.

29 Apr 2012 03:34 PM
Reply
lisarenee3505     
Ohhh subby... that's just... wow.

29 Apr 2012 03:41 PM
Reply
SharkTrager     
Your Average Witty Fark User: At the time, Kurt had just turned down a VERY lucrative offer from Lollapalooza, Nirvana was on the brink of breaking up, and Kurt was about to walk away from it all. Courtney's cash cow was going to dry up. To her, he was worth way, way more dead than alive

There is no way the name of the album Live Through This is a coincidence.

29 Apr 2012 03:53 PM
Reply
lisarenee3505     
Your Average Witty Fark User: zvoidx: Your Average Witty Fark User: Passive Aggressive Larry: Wasn't Cobain supposed to meet up with Michael Stipe shortly before he killed himself

That's awfully presumptuous. Tom Grant at least raises some very valid questions that have gone unanswered.

And to people who would doubt a motive; Courtney Love has already plowed through half a billion dollars since 1994.

At the time, Kurt had just turned down a VERY lucrative offer from Lollapalooza, Nirvana was on the brink of breaking up, and Kurt was about to walk away from it all. Courtney's cash cow was going to dry up. To her, he was worth way, way more dead than alive.

It pisses me off that more investigation hasn't been done into the questions Tom Grant raises. It's awfully, awfully troubling that he's raised these questions, and people close to the case have coincidentally turned up dead. I'm not saying she 100% is behind it, but I think it deserves investigation.


===================================== ======================

There is absolutely no way Love could have pulled something like this off on her own and gotten away with it. That girl is about a dumb as a bag of hammers, and she's always stoned (especially back then). There has to be someone else involved, and poor Courtney doesn't even realize that she's the fall-guy in the plan.

29 Apr 2012 04:01 PM
Reply
Surool     
Midnight Rambler: Passive Aggressive Larry: Cobain was such a fan of Automatic For the People

Yep. If I recall, Cobain had an R.E.M. CD in his player when they found his body.


Was "Everybody Hurts" on repeat? I'd blow my brains out too.

29 Apr 2012 04:41 PM
Reply
SharkTrager     
lisarenee3505: There is absolutely no way Love could have pulled something like this off on her own and gotten away with it. That girl is about a dumb as a bag of hammers, and she's always stoned (especially back then). There has to be someone else involved, and poor Courtney doesn't even realize that she's the fall-guy in the plan.

Look at her behavior before and after. She has the capacity to be very shrewd. Hell, she even managed to get people thinking she was respectable for a while after believably playing a freaking drug addled stripper who dies of AIDS. Her problem is that she's also nuts. She can't hold it together for an extended period.

The other thing to remember is that Kurt killing himself was so easy to believe. He was a junkie musician who always seemed depressed. It wouldn't have taken a criminal mastermind to make it seem like a suicide. Add in the build up with him missing after escaping rehab, and Courtney telling people she was worried he'd kill himself and you have it made. The cops were very likely to investigate it as a suicide because that's what they expected it to be.

29 Apr 2012 05:44 PM
Reply
FeedTheCollapse     
SharkTrager: lisarenee3505: There is absolutely no way Love could have pulled something like this off on her own and gotten away with it. That girl is about a dumb as a bag of hammers, and she's always stoned (especially back then). There has to be someone else involved, and poor Courtney doesn't even realize that she's the fall-guy in the plan.

Look at her behavior before and after. She has the capacity to be very shrewd. Hell, she even managed to get people thinking she was respectable for a while after believably playing a freaking drug addled stripper who dies of AIDS. Her problem is that she's also nuts. She can't hold it together for an extended period.

The other thing to remember is that Kurt killing himself was so easy to believe. He was a junkie musician who always seemed depressed. It wouldn't have taken a criminal mastermind to make it seem like a suicide. Add in the build up with him missing after escaping rehab, and Courtney telling people she was worried he'd kill himself and you have it made. The cops were very likely to investigate it as a suicide because that's what they expected it to be.


images.thecarconnection.com
"We've plenty of hearsay and conjecture. Those are kinds of evidence."


/if you think Courtney killed Kurt, you are admitting that your opinion should never be trusted.

29 Apr 2012 06:45 PM
Reply
kenfury     
Ms Fury just said to me.

"I'm surprised it hasn't leaked out now." I think we have trained her well my fellow farkers.

29 Apr 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
kenfury     
BumpInTheNight: LowbrowDeluxe: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Mentat: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

It was worth a shot.

Adolf Oliver Nipples: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Number one with a bullet, with widespread acclaim!

GungFu: Ah, the album he self released.

Proving yet again why I love Fark.

I agree, threads like these are such a blast!


I don't see why everyone needs to take such cheap shots.

29 Apr 2012 07:21 PM
Reply
ZeroCorpse    [TotalFark]  
For the last time, you goddamn idiots, Courtney did not kill Kurt.

She was famous a decade before he even started pursuing her and begging her to marry him. Hole did just fine before Kurt came along, and they had an album out before Nirvana. The album was doing quite well, too. People act as if Hole was just Courtney's work, but they were a competent, talented band with some great performers.

Courtney put up with Kurt's bullshiat, his abuse, his self-abuse, and the hero-worship his fans participated in. So many of his fans NEEDED to see her as the enemy because they were jealous of the woman who he gave his heart to. Remember: He pursued her. She tried to push him away and evade him at first, and he wouldn't take no for an answer, and he finally won her heart.

And that just PISSED OFF the fans. They couldn't bear to think their grunge hero was in love, and not the dejected, angsty, pain-ridden public image they desired.

But he was pain-ridden. He was a junkie who lashed out at everyone. Ask Dave Grohl about that. Kurt was a dick because he was a wastoid with no respect for other people. Courtney was a mess, too, but she was made MORE of a mess by his influence and behavior.

And then the stupid, selfish bastard kills himself, and the first thing his fans do is blame his wife. Nevermind that she was dealing with the lose of a spouse-- even if he was a pain in the ass and they were having problems-- He still deprived his daughter of a father, and in the middle of the shock and mourning of it all, the fans start calling the woman a murderer without a lick of evidence.

And so what happens? A private investigator/writer decides this is his ticket to the money train. He works out a story that supports the conclusion the Kurt fans want (that Courtney did it) and he whips out a book and movie, profiting greatly from the controversy he created/supported. Nevermind that the police investigated this high-profile case and concluded it was a suicide... According to the Kurt fans, a private dick who made a hefty profit selling his theory was the one who knew the "truth".

Nevermind that the private dick had limited access to everything having to do with the case, and he supported it with a lot of hearsay and conjecture, and he directly contradicted the police and the coroner in order to support his lucrative theory... The fans had to hate someone, and they damn well couldn't hate Kurt for being a selfish asshole, so they grabbed the "Courtney did it" theory and wandered around like morons spouting utter bullshiat, when they weren't there, had no first-hand knowledge of the situation, and have nothing but the made-up bullshiat lies of a private dick who made a fortune selling his theory to back up their hatred for Courtney.

Courtney used to be an incredibly clever woman, and she was also very generous and decent when she wasn't totally stoned. Kurt fell in love with her for a reason.

And then Kurt died, the world came down on her (without any evidence, but out of sheer selfish need to blame someone) and she went down fast. She used more and more, she lost her daughter, she fell apart and really started not to give a shiat anymore. She's a wreck now, and I can't help but think the selfish assholes who run around accusing her of murder even though they don't know shiat about Kurt and Courtney are a big part of the reason she's such a mess now.

You jumped on a widow and beat her down. Congratulations, dick-bags. I hope the world does the same to you when your spouse dies.

29 Apr 2012 08:01 PM
Reply
Surool     
ZeroCorpse: For the last time, you goddamn idiots, Courtney did not kill Kurt.

U Mad?

29 Apr 2012 08:14 PM
Reply
Benalto     
ZeroCorpse is on the ball. Forget if you love or hate Courtney, let's assume....whatever you want, the last day of Cobain's life.
During the preceding two weeks, Cobain was frequenting junkie hangouts, shocking people by being really sloppy about shooting up and amounts to shoot up. Dealers would watch him shoot up and kick him out of their apartment, not wanting to explain a dead body to the cops. Cobain already took a massive amount of heroin in Rome and survived. He did the same thing in Seattle but used the gun to make sure he wouldn't.
The last half year of Cobain's life...there are few things more depressing to read about. IF he was just suicidal, he might have been alive today. IF he was just a junkie, he might have been alive today. But he was both. Just.....ugh.

29 Apr 2012 08:27 PM
Reply
zvoidx     
ZeroCorpse: For the last time, you goddamn idiots, Courtney did not kill Kurt.

She was famous a decade before he even started pursuing her and begging her to marry him. Hole did just fine before Kurt came along, and they had an album out before Nirvana. The album was doing quite well, too. People act as if Hole was just Courtney's work, but they were a competent, talented band with some great performers.

Courtney put up with Kurt's bullshiat, his abuse, his self-abuse, and the hero-worship his fans participated in. So many of his fans NEEDED to see her as the enemy because they were jealous of the woman who he gave his heart to. Remember: He pursued her. She tried to push him away and evade him at first, and he wouldn't take no for an answer, and he finally won her heart.

And that just PISSED OFF the fans. They couldn't bear to think their grunge hero was in love, and not the dejected, angsty, pain-ridden public image they desired.

But he was pain-ridden. He was a junkie who lashed out at everyone. Ask Dave Grohl about that. Kurt was a dick because he was a wastoid with no respect for other people. Courtney was a mess, too, but she was made MORE of a mess by his influence and behavior.

And then the stupid, selfish bastard kills himself, and the first thing his fans do is blame his wife. Nevermind that she was dealing with the lose of a spouse-- even if he was a pain in the ass and they were having problems-- He still deprived his daughter of a father, and in the middle of the shock and mourning of it all, the fans start calling the woman a murderer without a lick of evidence.

And so what happens? A private investigator/writer decides this is his ticket to the money train. He works out a story that supports the conclusion the Kurt fans want (that Courtney did it) and he whips out a book and movie, profiting greatly from the controversy he created/supported. Nevermind that the police investigated this high-profile case and concluded it was a suicide... According to the Kurt ...


Did you read the book about his life/the case? It addresses what you're talking about. For one, Courtney showed up at his shows/was in the audience.

El Duce (singer from The Mentors) was captured on video (as it eventually appeared in an indie film Kurt&Courtney) stating that Courtney Love offered him $50,000 and he passed a polygraph:
Link
El Duce was found dead by the railroad a week after that was filmed.

29 Apr 2012 09:03 PM
Reply
invictus2     
meme.zenfs.com

29 Apr 2012 09:04 PM
Reply
germ78     
kenfury: BumpInTheNight: LowbrowDeluxe: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Mentat: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

It was worth a shot.

Adolf Oliver Nipples: germ78: I'm sure it would have exploded onto the charts.

Number one with a bullet, with widespread acclaim!

GungFu: Ah, the album he self released.

Proving yet again why I love Fark.

I agree, threads like these are such a blast!

I don't see why everyone needs to take such cheap shots.


Now, now. Don't lose your head over some pithy comments.

29 Apr 2012 10:25 PM
Reply
Your Average Witty Fark User     
ZeroCorpse: And so what happens? A private investigator/writer decides this is his ticket to the money train. He works out a story that supports the conclusion the Kurt fans want (that Courtney did it) and he whips out a book and movie, profiting greatly from the controversy he created/supported. Nevermind that the police investigated this high-profile case and concluded it was a suicide... According to the Kurt ...

Not only did Courtney HIRE Tom Grant (he didn't decide anything was his "money train") but you obviously haven't read the facts. He cant make up things like no fingerprints on the shell casing or the gun. That's not conjecture, that's a fact.

No one is saying Courtney pulled the trigger. However, if Tom Grant were able to take this evidence to a civil trial, there's a high likelihood that he'd win.

29 Apr 2012 10:30 PM
Reply
bigbadideasinaction     
Your Average Witty Fark User: ZeroCorpse: And so what happens? A private investigator/writer decides this is his ticket to the money train. He works out a story that supports the conclusion the Kurt fans want (that Courtney did it) and he whips out a book and movie, profiting greatly from the controversy he created/supported. Nevermind that the police investigated this high-profile case and concluded it was a suicide... According to the Kurt ...

Not only did Courtney HIRE Tom Grant (he didn't decide anything was his "money train") but you obviously haven't read the facts. He cant make up things like no fingerprints on the shell casing or the gun. That's not conjecture, that's a fact.

No one is saying Courtney pulled the trigger. However, if Tom Grant were able to take this evidence to a civil trial, there's a high likelihood that he'd win.


Ah yes, Tom Grant...

...how many days did it take for him to not find Kurt, cleverly hidden INSIDE HIS OWN FREAKING HOUSE?

Clearly we're dealing with an investigation of the highest quality here.

29 Apr 2012 10:58 PM
Reply
burning_bridge     
The My Little Pony Killer: Do not want. That stuff, if it exists, went unreleased for a reason. Stop suckling off his corpse and find your own gig already.

Maybe its not for you???

29 Apr 2012 11:50 PM
Reply
The My Little Pony Killer     
burning_bridge: The My Little Pony Killer: Do not want. That stuff, if it exists, went unreleased for a reason. Stop suckling off his corpse and find your own gig already.

Maybe its not for you???


Yes, my point exactly. Maybe it's not for anybody. Let it be.

30 Apr 2012 01:49 AM
Reply
burning_bridge     
The My Little Pony Killer: burning_bridge: The My Little Pony Killer: Do not want. That stuff, if it exists, went unreleased for a reason. Stop suckling off his corpse and find your own gig already.

Maybe its not for you???

Yes, my point exactly. Maybe it's not for anybody. Let it be.


Obviously some people disagree, hence what I said and then you said: not for you, so let it be. I don't understand why it matters to you so much what everyone else thinks, especially if they don't agree with you.

30 Apr 2012 02:07 AM
Reply
Showing 1-50 of 61 comments
Refresh Page 2
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Entertainment

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party