Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Main
   News: Frustration with government leads to secession talk. Fark: The Upper Peninsula seceding from Michigan

29 Apr 2012 06:44 PM   |   7993 clicks   |   Some Guy
Add Comment
Showing 51-100 of 146 comments
Page 1 Refresh Page 3
Mayhem of the Black Underclass     
♪♫Let dose yoopers go.♪♫

29 Apr 2012 07:26 PM
Reply
DrBear     
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!: Overfiend: As a Wisconsin resident, I would be happy to have the U.P. be part of our great state.

You can have Packer country, which is pretty much everything west of Marquette.
Escanaba.

Escanaba has the western UP's only CBS affil, which is basically the Green Bay station with weather cut-ins and local ads during station breaks.

29 Apr 2012 07:27 PM
Reply
LL316     
cyberspacedout: The peninsula could just start sucking up to the government of Wisconsin and ask to join their state. Then we all wouldn't have to buy new flags.

They're all Packer fans anyway. GFY's, U.P.

29 Apr 2012 07:28 PM
Reply
demaL-demaL-yeH    [TotalFark]  
dennysgod: robbrie: Good riddance!!! The UP is Alabama, only with a lot more snow.

/metro Detroiter
//not born here
///been to the UP exactly once and that was for a work conference

It's obvious you're not from Michigan otherwise you'd know that south central (just south of Lansing) is the "Alabama" of Michigan.

[2.bp.blogspot.com image 640x564]


Harold?

29 Apr 2012 07:28 PM
Reply
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!     
DrBear: Escanaba has the western UP's only CBS affil, which is basically the Green Bay station with weather cut-ins and local ads during station breaks.

But that's where we have our state fairgrounds.....life in east-central U.P. loses significance without the state fair!

29 Apr 2012 07:28 PM
Reply
farkityfarker     
RandomAxe: Michigan is nice in a lot of ways. Don't get me wrong.

I've heard that the trees there are just the right height.

29 Apr 2012 07:28 PM
Reply
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!     
LL316: They're all Packer fans anyway. GFY's, U.P.

Are not. Troll.

29 Apr 2012 07:29 PM
Reply
buster_v     
archive.perfectduluthday.com

Happy to see the Yoopers represent. Gives me a chance to favorite you so I know where you're from in the future.

29 Apr 2012 07:32 PM
Reply
Desquamation     
dennysgod: robbrie: Good riddance!!! The UP is Alabama, only with a lot more snow.

/metro Detroiter
//not born here
///been to the UP exactly once and that was for a work conference

It's obvious you're not from Michigan otherwise you'd know that south central (just south of Lansing) is the "Alabama" of Michigan.


My only problem with that map is that both Flint and Saginaw have just as many gangsters as Detroit.

/there are plenty of wannabes, though

29 Apr 2012 07:32 PM
Reply
Baz the Spaz     
www.beerinfo.com

Approves

29 Apr 2012 07:33 PM
Reply
jayphat     
AcademGreen: Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Atricle IV Sec 3 of the US Constitution:

 New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union; but no new State shall be formed or erected within the Jurisdiction of any other State; nor any State be formed by the Junction of two or more States, or Parts of States, without the Consent of the Legislatures of the States concerned as well as of the Congress.


I'm impressed someone actually knows the constitution. You have no business here in Fark.

29 Apr 2012 07:34 PM
Reply
Canton     
slayer199: We fought a war with Ohio over Toledo (why anyone wanted Toledo, I can't imagine). The U.P. was our consolation prize. It worked out well considering the mines in the U.P.

As for succession...not going to happen. I can't imagine the rest of the state going along with it.


Ahh, yes, the Toledo War, in which two militias pretty much failed to find each other in the swampy Toledo Strip. If I remember my history correctly, one guy got stabbed in a bar brawl. That was about as violent as the war got.

If only all wars worked out that way.

29 Apr 2012 07:34 PM
Reply
MikeMc     
asscorethethird: fark Michigan, They should just merge with Wisconsin. We have beer and cheese.

They should merge with the northern third of Wisconsin and form the largest economic and cultural wasteland in the Midwest.

29 Apr 2012 07:35 PM
Reply
RandomAxe    [TotalFark]  
farkityfarker: I've heard that the trees there are just the right height.

That is, in fact, a pretty fitting summation.

29 Apr 2012 07:36 PM
Reply
Sliding Carp    [TotalFark]  
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!:
We have our own song, tyvm. Link


What da hell's wrong with This one?

29 Apr 2012 07:39 PM
Reply
fanbladesaresharp     
Gyrfalcon: Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Why not?

No Cal and So Cal have been discussing it for years. Just depends on if the public vote allows it.


So has far northern CA and parts of Oregon into the state of "Jefferson", but there's not much talk about it anymore as most of the proponents are long dead.

29 Apr 2012 07:40 PM
Reply
Lupine Chemist    [TotalFark]  
Holy Wah!

29 Apr 2012 07:45 PM
Reply
Forty-Two    [TotalFark]  
dennysgod: It's obvious you're not from Michigan otherwise you'd know that south central (just south of Lansing) is the "Alabama" of Michigan.

I love that map. My dad is from the "Dutch People" area, and my mom is from the "Bible Belt"--though, in all honesty, I don't see much of a cultural difference between the two.

/They got better; they left Michigan.
//My cool, science-loving aunt and uncle moved from the Bible Belt to the UP. Also a good move.

29 Apr 2012 07:47 PM
Reply
Two_Noodles     
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!: Two_Noodles:
Sweet hoooome Yoopabama!
Where the Skies are sooo blue!

/rocks out

We have our own song, tyvm. Link


That song sucks. It combines all the worst elements of Springsteen and Bob Seger. Pretty Country though, so I hope you get adopted by a better musician.

29 Apr 2012 07:47 PM
Reply
cyberspacedout     
Last year in California there was a supervisor from Riverside County who proposed a new state with 13 counties in the southeastern part of the state. IIRC, few people took it seriously.

29 Apr 2012 07:54 PM
Reply
demaL-demaL-yeH    [TotalFark]  
Sliding Carp: NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!:
We have our own song, tyvm. Link

What da hell's wrong with This one?


It isn't turdy point buck or if she farts on da firs date (she's a keeper).

29 Apr 2012 07:55 PM
Reply
ChrisDe     
51st state? No.

11th Canadian province? Yes.

29 Apr 2012 07:58 PM
Reply
cryinoutloud     
Lady Beryl Ersatz-Wendigo: Meh, they are welcome to go. The landscape looks like Mars and the only point of interest is Tahquamenon Falls, unless you really, really like copper and fish.
We'll keep the fudge, thanks.


Wut.

lh5.googleusercontent.com

lh6.googleusercontent.com

lh5.googleusercontent.com

29 Apr 2012 08:00 PM
Reply
Vlad_the_Inaner    [TotalFark]  
Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Doesn't part of Texas's treaty to leave Mexico and join the US say it can split into 4 states if it wants to?

/expected them to do that in 2000 to put extra electors into the Electoral College if Bush v Gore didn't go the way they wanted in 2000.

29 Apr 2012 08:12 PM
Reply
sharkbeagle     
so 3 rows of 17 stars on the flag now?

29 Apr 2012 08:15 PM
Reply
goatleggedfellow    [TotalFark]  
Gyrfalcon: Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Why not?

No Cal and So Cal have been discussing it for years. Just depends on if the public vote allows it.


Totally laughable. Who wouldn't want to make a new state for themselves in a sparsely populated area, giving them two senators with overwhelmingly disproportionate representation? It's a blatant cry of "I like democracy so long as I get my way."

The Senate is just another pathetic old compromise to the wealthy Southern slavers. It needs to be completely reworked, but can't be.

29 Apr 2012 08:19 PM
Reply
BravadoGT    [TotalFark]  
They should call themselves "Eastconsin"

29 Apr 2012 08:25 PM
Reply
dennysgod     
Forty-Two: dennysgod: It's obvious you're not from Michigan otherwise you'd know that south central (just south of Lansing) is the "Alabama" of Michigan.

I love that map. My dad is from the "Dutch People" area, and my mom is from the "Bible Belt"--though, in all honesty, I don't see much of a cultural difference between the two.

/They got better; they left Michigan.
//My cool, science-loving aunt and uncle moved from the Bible Belt to the UP. Also a good move.


I grew up in the Confederate area and sadly it's spot on, luckily I got out before I was issued the Stars and Bars front plate.

29 Apr 2012 08:27 PM
Reply
eventhelosers     
Was in Manistique this winter (hospital being built). Hot bartender at the new bar, forgot the name. Lots of nice big houses on the lake for sale. Good place to raise kids I would think, although the lady at Big Boy or Dennys or whatever stated the obvious, all the young people leave. Would like to retire someplace like that, won't have to utter "get of my lawn" that often.

29 Apr 2012 08:33 PM
Reply
Generation_D     
Two_Noodles: They want to name themselves "Superior".

Which would be one of those natural "name means the opposite of what it is" things.

Next, Ted Nugent for governor, and the Michigan Militia for the state national guard.

29 Apr 2012 08:42 PM
Reply
demaL-demaL-yeH    [TotalFark]  
eventhelosers: Was in Manistique this winter (hospital being built). Hot bartender at the new bar, forgot the name. Lots of nice big houses on the lake for sale. Good place to raise kids I would think, although the lady at Big Boy or Dennys or whatever stated the obvious, all the young people leave. Would like to retire someplace like that, won't have to utter "get of my lawn" that often.

Hawt
hot or turdy pouns skinnier dan da udder unmarried snowbunnies wit teeth hot?

29 Apr 2012 08:44 PM
Reply
OtherLittleGuy     
slayer199: We fought a war with Ohio over Toledo (why anyone wanted Toledo, I can't imagine). The U.P. was our consolation prize. It worked out well considering the mines in the U.P.



Saw this on an episode of "How the States Were Made". Toledo was considered a big deal when it came for trade and travel on the Great Lakes. Ohio wouldn't let Michigan be admitted unless they gave up Toledo.

29 Apr 2012 08:45 PM
Reply
Yamaneko2    [TotalFark]  
leevis: Gyrfalcon: Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Why not?

No Cal and So Cal have been discussing it for years. Just depends on if the public vote allows it.

It has nothing to do with the public allowing it. It takes an act of congress to create a new state. Texas' constitution gives it the power to split up into five states but it won't happen unless the feds give the okay.


Texas' right to split into five states is written into Federal law as a condition of annexation. Any other state can split itself with Congress' permission. Any group of states can redistribute territory as they please or create new states within their midst, with Congressional approval and the approval of all state legislatures. For example, a Lower New York can be carved out of the New York metro area that currently covers New York, Connecticut and New Jersey if all three states agree to it and Congress approves.

From outside, it appears that the only part of Texas that is not "more Texan than thou" is the state's capital, Austin, so a breakup is unlikely.

29 Apr 2012 08:47 PM
Reply
armyguy35     
Hell yeaz!

/Live in Iron Mountain
//Kids are Kingsford Flivvers

29 Apr 2012 08:52 PM
Reply
Yamaneko2    [TotalFark]  
namatad: AcademGreen: Atricle IV Sec 3 of the US Constitution:

 New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union; but no new State shall be formed or erected within the Jurisdiction of any other State; nor any State be formed by the Junction of two or more States, or Parts of States, without the Consent of the Legislatures of the States concerned as well as of the Congress.

well the AWESOME part is that the GOP in congress will be TOTALLY supportive of any and all new states. right?
RIGHT??
Because states' rights are so important?!!@ LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL


Perhaps. Michigan is a narrowly Democratic state. The UP is strongly Democratic. Split the UP from the rest of the state, then instead of two Democratic senators as the norm, there will be two Democrats from the UP and two Republicans from the Lower Peninsula. The GOP would also gain the majority of electoral votes from present-day Michigan, where now it does not.

29 Apr 2012 08:54 PM
Reply
ChrisDe     
Yamaneko2: namatad: AcademGreen: Atricle IV Sec 3 of the US Constitution:

 New States may be admitted by the Congress into this Union; but no new State shall be formed or erected within the Jurisdiction of any other State; nor any State be formed by the Junction of two or more States, or Parts of States, without the Consent of the Legislatures of the States concerned as well as of the Congress.

well the AWESOME part is that the GOP in congress will be TOTALLY supportive of any and all new states. right?
RIGHT??
Because states' rights are so important?!!@ LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

Perhaps. Michigan is a narrowly Democratic state. The UP is strongly Democratic. Split the UP from the rest of the state, then instead of two Democratic senators as the norm, there will be two Democrats from the UP and two Republicans from the Lower Peninsula. The GOP would also gain the majority of electoral votes from present-day Michigan, where now it does not.


Detroit is pretty hardcore Democratic. To their dismay, if you look at elected officials like Coleman Young and Kwame Kilpatrick. But with the UAW throughout southeast Michigan, that's a firm Democratic base.

29 Apr 2012 09:08 PM
Reply
KarmaSpork     
Ja der hey.

/if you live there, you know what I mean

29 Apr 2012 09:10 PM
Reply
demaL-demaL-yeH    [TotalFark]  
KarmaSpork: Ja der hey.

/if you live there, you know what I mean


You took 75 south and forgot how to turn around?

/That must have been a good bender.

29 Apr 2012 09:12 PM
Reply
theorellior    [TotalFark]  
50 equal-population states.

uploads.neatorama.com

29 Apr 2012 09:15 PM
Reply
KarmaSpork     
demaL-demaL-yeH:
You took 75 south and forgot how to turn around?

/That must have been a good bender.


Can't say I miss climbing under trailers in 60 below to free up the brakes with a mini torch. I haven't seen snow in a year, and life is good!

29 Apr 2012 09:30 PM
Reply
flaminio     
sharkbeagle: so 3 rows of 17 stars on the flag now?

upload.wikimedia.org

29 Apr 2012 09:37 PM
Reply
blunto     
Do whatever you want Michigan, but I'm not buying a new flag.

29 Apr 2012 09:53 PM
Reply
Forty-Two    [TotalFark]  
theorellior: 50 equal-population states.

[uploads.neatorama.com image 640x377]


There's also a proposal for 38 states, with borders that reflect cultural similarities.
i139.photobucket.com

29 Apr 2012 09:54 PM
Reply
fanbladesaresharp     
goatleggedfellow: Gyrfalcon: Weaver95: now that's an interesting question...we already know that a state cannot leave the Union. the civil war settled that question for us. But can a state 'split off' into another state?

hmm.

Why not?

No Cal and So Cal have been discussing it for years. Just depends on if the public vote allows it.

Totally laughable. Who wouldn't want to make a new state for themselves in a sparsely populated area, giving them two senators with overwhelmingly disproportionate representation? It's a blatant cry of "I like democracy so long as I get my way."

The Senate is just another pathetic old compromise to the wealthy Southern slavers. It needs to be completely reworked, but can't be.


Sparsley? Don't know about that, depending on where the division is. Some want San Francisco area to be part of the north, all the way down to Fresno, some don't. But if population is an issue, look how many people live in the Dakotas, Wyoming and Alaska and they're states. They have counties larger than some eastern states.

29 Apr 2012 09:57 PM
Reply
AliceBToklasLives     

29 Apr 2012 09:57 PM
Reply
Aloy     
I wish NY would do this, so we could lose that festering pustule that is NYC.

29 Apr 2012 09:58 PM
Reply
Smackledorfer     
Forty-Two: dennysgod: It's obvious you're not from Michigan otherwise you'd know that south central (just south of Lansing) is the "Alabama" of Michigan.

I love that map. My dad is from the "Dutch People" area, and my mom is from the "Bible Belt"--though, in all honesty, I don't see much of a cultural difference between the two.

/They got better; they left Michigan.
//My cool, science-loving aunt and uncle moved from the Bible Belt to the UP. Also a good move.


I live in the "claims to be from detroit" section. Its true; they do, and many even get tattoos and shiat about it without ever living there.

29 Apr 2012 10:10 PM
Reply
detroitdoesntsuckthatbad     
Zero economic engine outside of an abandoned mining industry. Go for it, it'll keep the snow cows from migrating downstate once they graduate from Tech.

29 Apr 2012 10:13 PM
Reply
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!     
demaL-demaL-yeH: Sliding Carp: NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!:
We have our own song, tyvm. Link

What da hell's wrong with This one?

It isn't turdy point buck or if she farts on da firs date (she's a keeper).


I think my favorite was....what the hell is it......Fishin' Wit Fred.

29 Apr 2012 10:17 PM
Reply
demaL-demaL-yeH    [TotalFark]  
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!: .Fishin' Wit Fred.

Best line: "It's full o' terrorists from Ohio."

29 Apr 2012 10:22 PM
Reply
Showing 51-100 of 146 comments
Page 1 Refresh Page 3
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Main

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party