Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Main
   Lead Shrink on D.S.M. 4 says, "D.S.M. 5 promises to be a disaster that will medicalize normality, introduce Har Har Finks"

13 May 2012 06:49 PM   |   13412 clicks   |   The New York Times
Add Comment
Showing 1-50 of 178 comments
Refresh Page 2
simplicimus    [TotalFark]  
I'm sure there's a reason the author wrote this article. I'll check DSM5 in may.

13 May 2012 03:44 PM
Reply
A Terrible Human     
For some reason that article gives off Scientology like vibes.

13 May 2012 03:46 PM
Reply
cretinbob    [TotalFark]  
media.tumblr.com

13 May 2012 03:57 PM
Reply
namegoeshere     
As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

13 May 2012 04:13 PM
Reply
dahmers love zombie    [TotalFark]  
namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.


I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

13 May 2012 04:38 PM
Reply
A Terrible Human     
dahmers love zombie: I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

There isn't unless they just don't want to deal with them.

13 May 2012 04:47 PM
Reply
Asa Phelps    [TotalFark]  
dahmers love zombie: namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.


My reaction to the alarmism in the article and in the quoted text is "I would like to see some specific examples".

13 May 2012 06:02 PM
Reply
BlippityBleep     
Brave New World and 1984 sure are fighting for dominance in the beginning of the 21st century.

13 May 2012 06:50 PM
Reply
JasonOfOrillia    [TotalFark]  
How do you shrink lead?

/And is it a real plum bum?

13 May 2012 06:51 PM
Reply
greasybastard    [TotalFark]  
Is there a good way to jump the paywall?

13 May 2012 06:54 PM
Reply
Great Janitor     
Will D.S.M. 5 pick up the open ended plot lines that D.S.M. 4 failed to resolve?

13 May 2012 06:55 PM
Reply
BigLuca     
DSM 5 has Duke Nukem Forever Syndrome.

If it officially adds a Procrastination Syndrome I won't have to work another day in my life.

13 May 2012 06:56 PM
Reply
Kanemano     
Asa Phelps: dahmers love zombie: namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

My reaction to the alarmism in the article and in the quoted text is "I would like to see some specific examples".


link goes to another link that cites the studies, in footnotes

13 May 2012 06:56 PM
Reply
TanSau     
DS9?

13 May 2012 06:56 PM
Reply
Nina_Hartley's_Ass    [TotalFark]  
That's just crazy.

13 May 2012 06:57 PM
Reply
Gunny Walker    [TotalFark]  
i38.photobucket.com
Does it include sexual addiction?

13 May 2012 06:58 PM
Reply
Frank N Stein     
DSM is self service, politicized BS

13 May 2012 06:58 PM
Reply
ModernLuddite     
Smoke weed erry day?

13 May 2012 06:59 PM
Reply
BigLuca     
Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.

13 May 2012 07:00 PM
Reply
BlippityBleep     
you have a personality? that's a disorder, take these pills that will shorten your lifespan, kill your soul, but turn you into the cog we want you to be.

13 May 2012 07:00 PM
Reply
MrBentor     
And to think... ICD-10 is coming too.

13 May 2012 07:01 PM
Reply
MindStalker     
dahmers love zombie: namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.


Crack babies and heavily abused infants could theoretically have a need for such medication to get over their shock trauma.

13 May 2012 07:01 PM
Reply
Kumana Wanalaia     
As an Aberrant American, I say bring on the meds.

You don't want yours? Fine, more for me. NOM NOM NOM

13 May 2012 07:02 PM
Reply
cevk     
dahmers love zombie: namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.


Kids have seizures.

Medications that treat seizures need to cross the blood-brain barrier. This makes them psychotropic.

So yes, there are perfectly reasonable explanations for why infants would be taking psychotropic drugs.

13 May 2012 07:02 PM
Reply
PsiChick     
Yeeeah, I think it was pretty obvious when 4 came out that the political infighting is really shooting the entire field in the foot.

BigLuca: Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.


Same with Asperger's. The disorder has major and important differences from autism (especially that people with AS crave human contact\communication while autists may or may not), but why are they changing it? Because fark you, that's why.

This is not how you help people.

13 May 2012 07:03 PM
Reply
Cyrusv10     
JasonOfOrillia: How do you shrink lead?

/And is it a real plum bum?


I normally wiz past many of the comments on Fark, but yours was particularly bizarre and irrelevant. Can you please, umm, explain?

13 May 2012 07:04 PM
Reply
Kumana Wanalaia     
Cyrusv10:

Purple monkey dishwasher.

13 May 2012 07:05 PM
Reply
Kumana Wanalaia     
I GOT BEANS IN MY POCKETS

13 May 2012 07:06 PM
Reply
Glenford     
BigLuca: Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.


I used to work in an adolescent psychiatric unit. You know what Oppositional Defiance Disorder is? Adolescence. It has to be the biggest bullshiat diagnosis.

13 May 2012 07:06 PM
Reply
AliceBToklasLives     
Glenford: I used to work in an adolescent psychiatric unit. You know what Oppositional Defiance Disorder is? Adolescence. It has to be the biggest bullshiat diagnosis.

I was once told that pretty much everyone in prison has Antisocial Personality Disorder. This was said with a straight face by a mental health professional.

13 May 2012 07:10 PM
Reply
cherryl taggart     
MindStalker: dahmers love zombie: namegoeshere: As an Uninsured American, I am of course immune to all of these new psychiatric diagnoses.

It still scares the farking shiat out of me. For example: The report also found almost 4,000 foster and non-foster care infants - under a year old - on Medicaid in five states were taking psychotropic drugs. Researchers said the risks these drugs pose to children are "not well understood". Infants. Less than one year old. On psychotropic medication. Infants. Less than one year old.

I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

Crack babies and heavily abused infants could theoretically have a need for such medication to get over their shock trauma.


Nail on the head. Or, at least that is what we have been told whenever a kid arrives in our home with a baggie of prescription bottles in the diaper bag. The health department personnel aren't equipped to do much more than medicate. There's a whole lot of people out in the world that just want the baby to be quiet. Who cares if the baby needs to develop? Just be quiet baby.

13 May 2012 07:12 PM
Reply
GBmanNC     
BlippityBleep: you have a personality? that's a disorder, take these pills that will shorten your lifespan, kill your soul, but turn you into the cog we want you to be.

By definition of the word, a disorder is something that causes great distress. If the symptoms in the DSM are not greatly affecting ones life the DSM does not apply. If something in ones life is causing great distress that is worthy of trying to remedy, no?

Not to say some of the things in the DSM 5 might be crossing the line. Things like being able to add psychosomatic diagnoses to any physiologic diagnoses is a slippery slope. (have MS? Well now you have MS and psychosomatic illness, because come on, not all your fatigue is caused by MS!)

13 May 2012 07:13 PM
Reply
NobleHam     
Peer review and politics are the same thing, dummies.

Also, expanding the range of mental abnormalities or quirks covered by the DSM doesn't mean every abnormality must be medicated. The DSM seeks to cover the whole spectrum, not to imply that all parts of that spectrum are necessarily negative nor to to prescribe treatment to those which are.

13 May 2012 07:14 PM
Reply
thatboyoverthere     
AliceBToklasLives: Glenford: I used to work in an adolescent psychiatric unit. You know what Oppositional Defiance Disorder is? Adolescence. It has to be the biggest bullshiat diagnosis.

I was once told that pretty much everyone in prison has Antisocial Personality Disorder. This was said with a straight face by a mental health professional.


Antisocial Personalty Disorder is what Sociopaths and Psychopaths are. It's characterized by the fact that either you don't care if you hurt someone or actually go out of your way to do so. IE pretty much a lot of guys in prison. The guy might have been using hyperbole but he is right.

13 May 2012 07:15 PM
Reply
SurfaceTension    [TotalFark]  
And I'm feeling much better, now.

13 May 2012 07:15 PM
Reply
please_not_again     
Doug Stanhope on Prescription Drugs pretty much covers most of it in my opinion.

What are we (as a society) supposed to do when there is no sane way to deal with all the crazy shiat going on? When does "acting like everything is as fine as it was in the 90s" become the definition of mental illness, instead of the baseline for mental health we try to medicate to?

/you only know you're sane if the world drives you crazy

13 May 2012 07:15 PM
Reply
BigLuca     
PsiChick: Yeeeah, I think it was pretty obvious when 4 came out that the political infighting is really shooting the entire field in the foot.

BigLuca: Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.

Same with Asperger's. The disorder has major and important differences from autism (especially that people with AS crave human contact\communication while autists may or may not), but why are they changing it? Because fark you, that's why.

This is not how you help people.


Yeah I heard about that and don't really understand it. They are just lumping it into Autism Spectrum Disorder. I don't know the back story, but it seems like it is more of a coding and billing deal. I sense politics afoot.

13 May 2012 07:16 PM
Reply
kidsizedcoffin     
MrBentor: And to think... ICD-10 is coming too.

And the billing nightmare of every claim either being paid automatically or denied in error will cause massive employment gains as everyone rushes to fix this!

13 May 2012 07:17 PM
Reply
fragMasterFlash    [TotalFark]  
dahmers love zombie: I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

img19.imageshack.us

So if she gets knocked her babby will be formmed correctly, and require no medicine of any kind? Just try and convince the kids foster parents of that.

13 May 2012 07:18 PM
Reply
NIXON YOU DOLT!!!!!     
dahmers love zombie: I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

Phenobarbitol is considered a psychotropic medication, and is commonly used to treat substance withdrawals in newborns.

/off the top of my head.

13 May 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
JasonOfOrillia    [TotalFark]  
Cyrusv10: JasonOfOrillia: How do you shrink lead?

/And is it a real plum bum?

I normally wiz past many of the comments on Fark, but yours was particularly bizarre and irrelevant. Can you please, umm, explain?


I read the headline as Lead, as in the metal, shrink, as in the action, instead of as leading psychologist. The chemical symbol for lead is Pb from the Latin word Plumbum.

13 May 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
GilRuiz1     
i224.photobucket.com

13 May 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
thatboyoverthere     
Glenford: BigLuca: Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.

I used to work in an adolescent psychiatric unit. You know what Oppositional Defiance Disorder is? Adolescence. It has to be the biggest bullshiat diagnosis.


My mother that works with abused kids in the Wilder fountation disagrees. The think is that it does get overdiagnoised but Oppositional Defiance Disorder is where the kid will refuse to do even the simplest thing told to do even if it benefits them. Ask them if they want to eat and they will argue with you that they're not hungry so you give up. Then 30 minutes later they will start screaming at you that their hungry and why didn't you feed them.

13 May 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
Jixa     
dahmers love zombie: I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.


I'm sure GlaxoSmithKline, Pfizer, AstraZeneca and the other pharmaceutical companies could conceive of several billion monetary reasons.

Because everyone is sick and even if you're not, there's a pill for that too.

13 May 2012 07:19 PM
Reply
Mentalpatient87     
Oppositional Defiance Disorder: "Why don't you quit bein' a batch and pill me up!"

13 May 2012 07:20 PM
Reply
namegoeshere     
GBmanNC: BlippityBleep: you have a personality? that's a disorder, take these pills that will shorten your lifespan, kill your soul, but turn you into the cog we want you to be.

By definition of the word, a disorder is something that causes great distress. If the symptoms in the DSM are not greatly affecting ones life the DSM does not apply. If something in ones life is causing great distress that is worthy of trying to remedy, no?


I have a problem with this when it comes to children. Because children cannot be in charge of their own healthcare. So perhaps it is causing great distress - to the parents. But perhaps it is not due to an organic disorder, but shiatty parenting. As has been said, Oppositional Defiant Disorder. Or, "angry/irritable mood", "defiant/headstrong behavior"... Now no longer any fault of the parent, as evidenced by this handy diagnosis and these helpful pills.

13 May 2012 07:20 PM
Reply
Mentalpatient87     
Goddamn farking autocorrect...

13 May 2012 07:21 PM
Reply
PsiChick     
BigLuca: PsiChick: Yeeeah, I think it was pretty obvious when 4 came out that the political infighting is really shooting the entire field in the foot.

BigLuca: Some changes ... "It is proposed that the eight symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder should be divided into the following categories: Angry/Irritable Mood; Defiant/Headstrong Behavior; and Vindictiveness."

And do you know why they are changing that? Because fark you, that's why.

Same with Asperger's. The disorder has major and important differences from autism (especially that people with AS crave human contact\communication while autists may or may not), but why are they changing it? Because fark you, that's why.

This is not how you help people.

Yeah I heard about that and don't really understand it. They are just lumping it into Autism Spectrum Disorder. I don't know the back story, but it seems like it is more of a coding and billing deal. I sense politics afoot.


If it wasn't, I have a feeling the news articles would involve something resembling a reason instead of just basic commentary. That, or, "Infuriated shrinks take to streets after being ridiculously misrepresented by media" would suddenly be a story.

13 May 2012 07:21 PM
Reply
Smidge204     
dahmers love zombie: I cannot conceive of a single legitimate medical reason for this.

Those infants were babbling incoherently, grasping at imaginary objects in mid-air, and soiling themselves constantly. Most of them are so disconnected they can't even stand. They clearly need the meds.
=Smidge=

13 May 2012 07:22 PM
Reply
J. Frank Parnell    [TotalFark]  
They told me i was crazy, but i showed them!

/the bodies

13 May 2012 07:24 PM
Reply
Showing 1-50 of 178 comments
Refresh Page 2
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Main

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party