Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Main
   Japanese officials to small NJ town: "We'd be much obliged if you'd tear down your memorial to abused 'comfort women' of WWII." NJ town: "How about 'NO'... and btw, welcome to the Streisand Effect"

20 May 2012 10:21 AM   |   19137 clicks   |   Japan Today
Add Comment
Showing 1-50 of 198 comments
Refresh Page 2
tillerman35     
Love, soft as an easy chair?

20 May 2012 10:23 AM
Reply
SharkTrager     
Why is there a Korean Comfort Woman Memorial in New Jersey?

20 May 2012 10:24 AM
Reply
fluffy2097     
Wait, What exactly does the statue commemorate?

Is this like?
"These young women were abused and wronged and we will forever remember them to try and make up for it."

Or because it's NJ, is it more like
"YEAAAAHHHHH!!!! ASIAN HOOKERS RULE! YEAAAHHH! LETS GO TANNING!"

Because if it's the latter, I can see someone taking issue with it.

20 May 2012 10:25 AM
Reply
PonceAlyosha     
SharkTrager: Why is there a Korean Comfort Woman Memorial in New Jersey?

Central Jersey has a large Korean population.

20 May 2012 10:26 AM
Reply
JasonOfOrillia    [TotalFark]  
fluffy2097: Wait, What exactly does the statue commemorate?

Is this like?
"These young women were abused and wronged and we will forever remember them to try and make up for it."

Or because it's NJ, is it more like
"YEAAAAHHHHH!!!! ASIAN HOOKERS RULE! YEAAAHHH! LETS GO TANNING!"

Because if it's the latter, I can see someone taking issue with it.


If it were the latter it would be the Koreans taking issue with it.

20 May 2012 10:28 AM
Reply
foo monkey     
PonceAlyosha: SharkTrager: Why is there a Korean Comfort Woman Memorial in New Jersey?

Central Jersey has a large Korean population.


Northern NJ too. Palisades is hardly central. Nearly every business on the West side of the Hudson has English/Korean signage. It's like Quebec, except the Korean-Americans aren't douchey about it.

20 May 2012 10:31 AM
Reply
cynicalbastard     
There are many admirable things about the Japanese. Their bigotry is not one of those things. Take a neo-Nazi skinhead, crossbreed him with a Daughters of the Confederacy bimbo from Mobile, Alabama , and give the result slightly slanted eyes and you would barely come close to Japanese attitudes regarding other "races".

20 May 2012 10:33 AM
Reply
Allen. The end.    [TotalFark]  
foo monkey: Northern NJ too. Palisades is hardly central. Nearly every business on the West side of the Hudson has English/Korean signage. It's like Quebec, except the Korean-Americans aren't douchey about it.

I like bilingual signage.

20 May 2012 10:33 AM
Reply
krackpipe     
It's OK to say "No", but I hope we're not indignant. If we're indignant, it won't leave us room for complaining if, somewhere in Iraq, they build a memorial to the 100,000 or more Iraqi civilians we killed between 2003-2011, thanks to the brilliant (Bush administration) decision to go to war there without a reason other than to make our nation hated by the world and trillions in debt.

20 May 2012 10:39 AM
Reply
Gosling     
cynicalbastard: There are many admirable things about the Japanese. Their bigotry is not one of those things. Take a neo-Nazi skinhead, crossbreed him with a Daughters of the Confederacy bimbo from Mobile, Alabama , and give the result slightly slanted eyes and you would barely come close to Japanese attitudes regarding other "races".

Pretty much. The Japanese are cool in a lot of respects, but their racial tolerance isn't one of them.

Also class tolerance. Ever hear of burukumin?

20 May 2012 10:39 AM
Reply
jeffowl     
If you look at some other stories from the local area, it would seem that the Japanese folks thought that the memorial was over the top and exaggerated the horrible things that happened. One article even suggested that the position of the Japanese officials was that women "served the soldiers willingly." (www.northjersey.com search "comfort women" I couldn't get a direct link to work)

20 May 2012 10:40 AM
Reply
SockMonkeyHolocaust    [TotalFark]  
Pennsauken, NJ has a memorial dedicated to all the people who died in 9/11 despite not having any people remotely involved in the tragedy. They took years and a lot of money to decide where to put a Vietnam Vets memorial but that 9/11 one was up in no time.

20 May 2012 10:42 AM
Reply
StoPPeRmobile     
t2.gstatic.com

20 May 2012 10:42 AM
Reply
mekki     
cynicalbastard: There are many admirable things about the Japanese. Their bigotry is not one of those things. Take a neo-Nazi skinhead, crossbreed him with a Daughters of the Confederacy bimbo from Mobile, Alabama , and give the result slightly slanted eyes and you would barely come close to Japanese attitudes regarding other "races".

For a culture that is supposedly all about shame they are very shameless about their ongoing bigotry as well as denying or covering up the atrocities they did in WWII. And the sad fact is, there are many people out there who have bough the Japanese PR WWII campaign and think that the Japanese were just helpless victims and there were nothing more than kittens with guns trying to defend themselves and taking orders from big, bad Germany.

20 May 2012 10:45 AM
Reply
LegenDruss     
From the comments section of the article...
"But any Japanese who has a problem with this plaque should have his head bounced off it until he thanks the makers of it for pointing out the truth of history."

THIS

History lessons courtesy of Joe Pesci!

20 May 2012 10:45 AM
Reply
BronyMedic     
fark these people, and their revisionist history.

The attitudes between Japan and Germany when dealing with their role in the atrocities of World War II are a start contrast. While Germans admitted responsibility, and took a role in acknowledging and trying to prevent further atrocity, (Go ahead. Go into Germany and say the holocaust was warranted, or never really happened. I dare you to.) the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished. There are a large and vocal group of Japanese politicians and scholars which seek to even justify, and minimize the impact Japan had in these events.

20 May 2012 10:46 AM
Reply
fireclown     
Only the Japanese government would even think of doing this.

20 May 2012 10:48 AM
Reply
Rwa2play    [TotalFark]  
Gosling: cynicalbastard: There are many admirable things about the Japanese. Their bigotry is not one of those things. Take a neo-Nazi skinhead, crossbreed him with a Daughters of the Confederacy bimbo from Mobile, Alabama , and give the result slightly slanted eyes and you would barely come close to Japanese attitudes regarding other "races".

Pretty much. The Japanese are cool in a lot of respects, but their racial tolerance isn't one of them.


That's pretty much the gist of it. Unlike Germany, Japan has tried to sweep their actions in WWII under the rug (so no wonder the Korean and Chinese get pissed at them real easy). So until they pretty much admit to the things they did in WWII and do what the Germans did, it'll never be over.

Worse: the generation that took part in those atrocities is slowly dying out and the younger generation is starting to be aware of it.

Also class tolerance. Ever hear of burukumin?

No, but again I wouldn't be surprised. Ever since the Meiji Restoration there's being a separation of classes that's even survived WWII; look at the whole controversy surrounding the nuclear plant post-earthquake. A lot of back-scratching was done being politicians and officials to keep what was really happening at the plant quiet.

20 May 2012 10:51 AM
Reply
Allen. The end.    [TotalFark]  
BronyMedic: fark these people, and their revisionist history.

The attitudes between Japan and Germany when dealing with their role in the atrocities of World War II are a start contrast. While Germans admitted responsibility, and took a role in acknowledging and trying to prevent further atrocity, (Go ahead. Go into Germany and say the holocaust was warranted, or never really happened. I dare you to.) the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished. There are a large and vocal group of Japanese politicians and scholars which seek to even justify, and minimize the impact Japan had in these events.


Stark. The word you are looking for is stark. Are you even trying?

20 May 2012 10:52 AM
Reply
SweetHomeNowhere     
foo monkey: Northern NJ too. Palisades is hardly central. Nearly every business on the West side of the Hudson has English/Korean signage. It's like Quebec, except the Korean-Americans aren't douchey about it.

And the Korean-American population is getting bigger in NJ now that NYC's Korean-American population is moving elsewhere.

Gosling: Also class tolerance. Ever hear of burukumin?

You mean Burakumin.

I'm half-Japanese myself (my mother's side of the family is actually from a Burakumin ancestry) and Japan is still stuck in a 19th century Feudal society. We westerners keep thinking that Japan is a democratic country. Japan of today is very similar to the Victorian England without the religious burden.

20 May 2012 10:54 AM
Reply
Kuta     
Japanese official quoted as saying, "She needed comfort. So I gave my Korean girl a hug, in the tunnel of love."

20 May 2012 10:55 AM
Reply
BronyMedic     
Allen. The end.: Stark. The word you are looking for is stark. Are you even trying?

Behold. The miracles of posting on an iPhone.

20 May 2012 10:57 AM
Reply
mekki     
krackpipe: It's OK to say "No", but I hope we're not indignant. If we're indignant, it won't leave us room for complaining if, somewhere in Iraq, they build a memorial to the 100,000 or more Iraqi civilians we killed between 2003-2011, thanks to the brilliant (Bush administration) decision to go to war there without a reason other than to make our nation hated by the world and trillions in debt.

Here's the thing, we wouldn't complain if they did. It has happened before. In Japan, they have a statue of Sadako Sasaki, a little girl who went through a horrible death as result of US bombing. As well as an entire memorial, Nagasaki National Peace Memorial Hall for the Atomic Bomb Victims. No American officials, as far as I have read, have objected to that statue.

20 May 2012 10:57 AM
Reply
JWideman     
jeffowl: If you look at some other stories from the local area, it would seem that the Japanese folks thought that the memorial was over the top and exaggerated the horrible things that happened. One article even suggested that the position of the Japanese officials was that women "served the soldiers willingly." (www.northjersey.com search "comfort women" I couldn't get a direct link to work)

And the Bataan Death March? That was line dancing.

20 May 2012 11:00 AM
Reply
MBooda     
This morning while I was reading FARK,
I saw a link about Palisades Park;
Protesting brothels that the Japanese built,
That's where the girls were.

You'll never know how lousy sex can feel,
When you're underneath the Nippon Army bootheel,
That's what the memorial said,
Down at Palisades Park.
Down at Palisades Park.

20 May 2012 11:03 AM
Reply
Shimagaijin     
1.bp.blogspot.com

Old news...

...Futemna anyone?

20 May 2012 11:04 AM
Reply
HopScotchNSoda     
MBooda: This morning while I was reading FARK,
I saw a link about Palisades Park;
Protesting brothels that the Japanese built,
That's where the girls were.

You'll never know how lousy sex can feel,
When you're underneath the Nippon Army bootheel,
That's what the memorial said,
Down at Palisades Park.
Down at Palisades Park.



Sonny Sixkiller approves.
theportlandreview.files.wordpress.com

20 May 2012 11:09 AM
Reply
mesmer242     
mekki: krackpipe: It's OK to say "No", but I hope we're not indignant. If we're indignant, it won't leave us room for complaining if, somewhere in Iraq, they build a memorial to the 100,000 or more Iraqi civilians we killed between 2003-2011, thanks to the brilliant (Bush administration) decision to go to war there without a reason other than to make our nation hated by the world and trillions in debt.

Here's the thing, we wouldn't complain if they did. It has happened before. In Japan, they have a statue of Sadako Sasaki, a little girl who went through a horrible death as result of US bombing. As well as an entire memorial, Nagasaki National Peace Memorial Hall for the Atomic Bomb Victims. No American officials, as far as I have read, have objected to that statue.


I've been to the (US) National Museum of Nuclear Science & History, and there's an entire wall of pictures from Hiroshima. It's not shied away from at all, and it's not presented in a "rah-rah go US" way either. It's definitely presented as a tough, sad decision that not everyone agrees was the right one.

20 May 2012 11:10 AM
Reply
Rwa2play    [TotalFark]  
mekki: krackpipe: It's OK to say "No", but I hope we're not indignant. If we're indignant, it won't leave us room for complaining if, somewhere in Iraq, they build a memorial to the 100,000 or more Iraqi civilians we killed between 2003-2011, thanks to the brilliant (Bush administration) decision to go to war there without a reason other than to make our nation hated by the world and trillions in debt.

Here's the thing, we wouldn't complain if they did. It has happened before. In Japan, they have a statue of Sadako Sasaki, a little girl who went through a horrible death as result of US bombing.


Which I find laughable and sad at the same time. They never want to realize that it was their leaders that led to the deaths of innocent people like her, never want to admit what the Germans had to in order to move forward.

As well as an entire memorial, Nagasaki National Peace Memorial Hall for the Atomic Bomb Victims. No American officials, as far as I have read, have objected to that statue.

I think no one sane would ever object to that.

20 May 2012 11:12 AM
Reply
mikdeetx     
Since they tore down the roller coaster in Palisades Park years ago, what else are they going to ride?

20 May 2012 11:14 AM
Reply
Gosling     
SweetHomeNowhere: You mean Burakumin.

My mistake; sorry about that.

20 May 2012 11:15 AM
Reply
GoTarHeels     
MBooda: This morning while I was reading FARK,
I saw a link about Palisades Park;
Protesting brothels that the Japanese built,
That's where the girls were.

You'll never know how lousy sex can feel,
When you're underneath the Nippon Army bootheel,
That's what the memorial said,
Down at Palisades Park.
Down at Palisades Park.


Thanks, pal. Now that will be playing in my head all day.

20 May 2012 11:18 AM
Reply
some_beer_drinker    [TotalFark]  
www.japanprobe.com

20 May 2012 11:19 AM
Reply
HopScotchNSoda     
Rwa2play: mekki: As well as an entire memorial, Nagasaki National Peace Memorial Hall for the Atomic Bomb Victims. No American officials, as far as I have read, have objected to that statue.

I think no one sane would ever object to that.



Heh, you don't know the Japs then. If the situation was reversed, they would whine and insist that it is an inaccurate and unfair characterisation.

20 May 2012 11:19 AM
Reply
cig-mkr     
Only in New Jersey would there be a monument to Korean sex slaves.
picture of said monument?
voicesofny.org

20 May 2012 11:19 AM
Reply
Unsung_Hero     
The best response might have been, "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."

Then I'd ask them if they'd like to forget about Hiroshima and Nagasaki along with the 'comfort women'.

20 May 2012 11:20 AM
Reply
HopScotchNSoda     
www.bergennews.com
www.thebestpageintheuniverse.net

20 May 2012 11:22 AM
Reply
ladyfortuna     
fireclown: Only the Japanese government would even think of doing this.

I think it's more because there's a pervasive attitude in Japan; after all, they've had a whole bunch of Prime Ministers over the last decade or so, because they keep resigning in disgrace over scandals or bad economies. I don't follow it closely but I know I've seen at least 3.So 'the government' over there keeps changing, but the culture continues to deny how far they went in WWII...

20 May 2012 11:22 AM
Reply
Gregosaurus     
Guess so. I've lived one town away for 9 years & this is the first time I've ever heard of it.

/Way to go, Streisand-San.

20 May 2012 11:23 AM
Reply
HopScotchNSoda     
Their problem plobrem with it is that raping wasn't committed by Japanese soldiers. As their government have tried for years to explain, the real culprits were dorlfins.

20 May 2012 11:28 AM
Reply
Allen. The end.    [TotalFark]  
BronyMedic: Allen. The end.: Stark. The word you are looking for is stark. Are you even trying?

Behold. The miracles of posting on an iPhone.


Ah, gotcha. My bad.

20 May 2012 11:32 AM
Reply
Medic Zero     
BronyMedic: fark these people, and their revisionist history.

The attitudes between Japan and Germany when dealing with their role in the atrocities of World War II are a start contrast. While Germans admitted responsibility, and took a role in acknowledging and trying to prevent further atrocity, (Go ahead. Go into Germany and say the holocaust was warranted, or never really happened. I dare you to.) the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished. There are a large and vocal group of Japanese politicians and scholars which seek to even justify, and minimize the impact Japan had in these events.


Not only this, but they actually teach in their schools that WWII was all our fault, "The War of American Aggression". They don't acknowledge ANY of their role in causing the war, much less their atrocities.

20 May 2012 11:36 AM
Reply
gblive     
The list of Japanese atrocities in WWII is endless:
- the Rape of Nanking
- the Bataan Death March
- Unit 731 Biological Weapons Research


.... and many, many more.

Yet, the Japanese play the victim card for the dropping of the atomic bombs every year while denying all the crimes they committed in WWII.

20 May 2012 11:38 AM
Reply
One Bad Apple    [TotalFark]  
BronyMedic:

the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished.


There were no Simon Wiesethal types in Asia. The culture of ancestor worship runs too deep for the Japanese to ever treat their role in WW2 like the Germans

20 May 2012 11:41 AM
Reply
dwhy_clist     
I hope they have tours and give out pamphlets when the F1 circus comes to the area in 2014 - that would torque the Japanese up to 11.

20 May 2012 11:42 AM
Reply
sycraft     
It has been a problem with Japanese culture since the war, and I don't know if it will ever get fixed. They just cannot face what they did for some reason. Shame maybe, I dunno. However it is the sort of thing they just feel the need to push aside and try to forget it ever happened, and as such get mad when they get reminded of it.

It is annoying because all that anyone (well ok, almost anyone) is asking is for them to acknowledge and remember. I don't see outcries for reparations or anything (which I wouldn't support) just for them to own up to what happened, and not to push it aside and forget.

It is worrying too since the whole "Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it," thing is not without merit. Remembering what your country did, why it did it, and the kind of arguments that were used to support it can help you identify if someone is trying it again.

They really need to collectively man up, put on their big boy pantz, say "Yep, we did bad shiat during the war and here's what it was," teach it to their kids, and simply make it a part of their history.

20 May 2012 11:50 AM
Reply
Injuneer     
Funniest 2012-05-20 11:36:16 AM BronyMedic: fark these people, and their revisionist history.

The attitudes between Japan and Germany when dealing with their role in the atrocities of World War II are a start contrast. While Germans admitted responsibility, and took a role in acknowledging and trying to prevent further atrocity, (Go ahead. Go into Germany and say the holocaust was warranted, or never really happened. I dare you to.) the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished. There are a large and vocal group of Japanese politicians and scholars which seek to even justify, and minimize the impact Japan had in these events.
Not only this, but they actually teach in their schools that WWII was all our fault, "The War of American Aggression". They don't acknowledge ANY of their role in causing the war, much less their atrocities.

The US gov't likely played the biggest role by allowing the Emperor to stay in power. While the Jap emperor was not as guilty as Hitler, all he had to do was say "No", loudly, and all that aggression would have stopped. As a result of keeping him in power, and that the Japs leaders were not as well known as Hitlers crew, and you have the Jap bad guys still in power decades later.

20 May 2012 11:51 AM
Reply
Gaylord Fister     
You're a sap, Mr. Jap.

20 May 2012 11:52 AM
Reply
Malcolm_Sex     
BronyMedic: fark these people, and their revisionist history.

The attitudes between Japan and Germany when dealing with their role in the atrocities of World War II are a start contrast. While Germans admitted responsibility, and took a role in acknowledging and trying to prevent further atrocity, (Go ahead. Go into Germany and say the holocaust was warranted, or never really happened. I dare you to.) the majority of the Japanese involved in such heinous events as the Rape of Nanking, the Comfort Women, the Bataan Death March, Unit 731 and biological warfare experiments on civilians and prisoners of war, and even human vivisections of POWs went largely unpunished. There are a large and vocal group of Japanese politicians and scholars which seek to even justify, and minimize the impact Japan had in these events.


The sad thing is it works. 90% of people don't even know about any of the farked up shiat they did in WWII

20 May 2012 11:57 AM
Reply
kroonermanblack     
Gosling: cynicalbastard: There are many admirable things about the Japanese. Their bigotry is not one of those things. Take a neo-Nazi skinhead, crossbreed him with a Daughters of the Confederacy bimbo from Mobile, Alabama , and give the result slightly slanted eyes and you would barely come close to Japanese attitudes regarding other "races".

Pretty much. The Japanese are cool in a lot of respects, but their racial tolerance isn't one of them.

Also class tolerance. Ever hear of burukumin?


They sound like 'untouchables'. Lots of caste systems have them?

I'm not disagreeing that the culture (race?) is wierd, highly racist and classist, and was extremely xenophobic for a long time (is it still?).

But Japanese culture as a whole seems to come from an angle Americans can't understand readily.

20 May 2012 11:58 AM
Reply
Showing 1-50 of 198 comments
Refresh Page 2
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Main

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party