Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Main
   Illinois adds $1 sales tax to cigarettes to help fund Medicaid

26 May 2012 01:17 PM   |   3484 clicks   |   Chicago Sun-Times
Add Comment
Showing 1-50 of 195 comments
Refresh Page 2
cman    [TotalFark]  
I wonder how much money can be made in cigarette smuggling to these high taxed areas

26 May 2012 11:14 AM
Reply
Donnchadha    [TotalFark]  
This is Unamerican!

Keep government out of my Medicaid!

26 May 2012 11:58 AM
Reply
Pud    [TotalFark]  
cman: I wonder how much money can be made in cigarette smuggling to these high taxed areas


Just look back about 10 yrs. ago when NY did this. It created a whole new black market, complete with hijacking trucks, and smuggling cancer sticks across the border from NJ.

/Some of the stories were right here on Fark.

26 May 2012 12:01 PM
Reply
MaudlinMutantMollusk    [TotalFark]  
What could possibly go wrong?

26 May 2012 12:04 PM
Reply
BronyMedic     
Donnchadha: Keep government out of my Medicaid!

Considering a huge burdon on Medicaid and Medicare is caused by elderly smokers with COPD, and the majority of those cases are caused by life-long cigarette use, I'm ok with this.

26 May 2012 01:19 PM
Reply
bim1154     
And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

26 May 2012 01:20 PM
Reply
BlippityBleep     
authoritarian farkheads.

26 May 2012 01:21 PM
Reply
Jon iz teh kewl     
if we outlaw cigarettes everywhere, we can make tons more money. and then hand the government a check with our illegal income. and say do whatever with it!!

26 May 2012 01:21 PM
Reply
RibbyK     
www.biography.com
Approves

26 May 2012 01:21 PM
Reply
ArcadianRefugee     
cman: I wonder how much money can be made in cigarette smuggling to these high taxed areas

A lot.

/not that I would know firsthand, of course
//nope

26 May 2012 01:23 PM
Reply
DeathByGeekSquad     
Wisconsin and Indiana will see an uptick in business....

26 May 2012 01:24 PM
Reply
SpikeStrip    [TotalFark]  
one dollar cheetos tax coming soon.

26 May 2012 01:27 PM
Reply
RibbyK     
bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

That's about half the rate for a new car in California. Everytime I visit Chicago I think "what crappy roads", then I remember this story: Link

CSB I worked with Joey Palumbo on highways 47 & 176 many moons ago, nice guy but obviously following in his father's footsteps.

26 May 2012 01:27 PM
Reply
aevert     
DeathByGeekSquad: Wisconsin and Indiana will see an uptick in business....

Seriously. The borders for those states are an hour or less from Illinois' largest population center (in good traffic).

26 May 2012 01:27 PM
Reply
jim32rr    [TotalFark]  
bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

You are correct. Considering a move outta here.

26 May 2012 01:28 PM
Reply
LeroyBourne     
After everyone quits there will be a fat tax. After everyone is skinny and fit there will be an iq tax. After everyone is well educated, I have no idea what they'll tax, but I'll be long dead by then and don't care.

26 May 2012 01:28 PM
Reply
Professczar     
bim1154: I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

This.

26 May 2012 01:28 PM
Reply
Trance750    [TotalFark]  
I'm OK with that

26 May 2012 01:28 PM
Reply
TheGreatGazoo    [TotalFark]  
This is good news for Missouri, Kentucky, Iowa, Wisconsin, and Indiana cigarette sellers.

26 May 2012 01:29 PM
Reply
Shostie    [TotalFark]  
And of course by "Medicaid" they mean "the general fund."

26 May 2012 01:29 PM
Reply
rfronk     
bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

My tags are $300 this month here in Kansas. $220 for a 6 year old vehicle and $80 for a 15 year old vehicle.

26 May 2012 01:30 PM
Reply
Jon iz teh kewl     
jim32rr: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

You are correct. Considering a move outta here.


don't move here

26 May 2012 01:30 PM
Reply
bim1154     
SpikeStrip: one dollar cheetos tax coming soon.

And if it hasn't gone through yet, soft drinks too. I think they may have taxed bottled water, but can't remember.

RibbyKBack in the 70s when I worked for my father, we use to work on a lot of construction company vehicles and we saw plenty of that. I do remember the story in your link as that's more recent.

26 May 2012 01:30 PM
Reply
KrispyKritter    [TotalFark]  
meanwhile they could decriminalize & regulate sale of 420 and have Mad income nearly overnight. wishful thinking considering you can't even smoke your cigarette in a farking Bar, disco or anywhere else public that tax paying adults live their lives.

26 May 2012 01:31 PM
Reply
LargeCanine     
i137.photobucket.com

I say we tax all foreigners living abroad.

26 May 2012 01:31 PM
Reply
Gunny Walker    [TotalFark]  
I say we kill of this Medicaid right now. Can't the private market do better? The government can't seem to turn a profit on it.

/Death Panels!

26 May 2012 01:32 PM
Reply
DrewCurtisJr     
BronyMedic: Considering a huge burdon on Medicaid and Medicare is caused by elderly smokers with COPD, and the majority of those cases are caused by life-long cigarette use, I'm ok with this.

It's not like smokes aren't taxed to death already. Smokers already pay more in taxes than they burden the health care systems. This is just a tax increase, not an offset to pay for the negative effects of smoking.

26 May 2012 01:32 PM
Reply
bim1154     
jim32rr: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

You are correct. Considering a move outta here.


I'm in Lake county and can escape some things but not the license plate thing. I'd leave this state in a heartbeat but our two sons are fairly established career wise and I don't see it happening soon.

26 May 2012 01:32 PM
Reply
ceewayne     
If you think the money is going to Medicaid, I got a bridge to sell you in Florida. Just look at the schools in Illinois flush with the money from the casinos....

26 May 2012 01:32 PM
Reply
BlippityBleep     
in another few years they'll be on to taxing fatties, and i can't wait to vote the shiat out of upping taxes for fatassery causing habits.

26 May 2012 01:33 PM
Reply
bim1154     
rfronk: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

My tags are $300 this month here in Kansas. $220 for a 6 year old vehicle and $80 for a 15 year old vehicle.


FU(K! Is that for cars?

26 May 2012 01:33 PM
Reply
RoyBatty     
FTA:

In addition to cigarettes, the current legislation increases the tax on packs of "roll-your-own" cigarettes, "little cigars", moist snuff, electronic cigarettes, and a 5 cent increase on each pack of candy cigarettes.

Sigh, I am forced to agree, this sounds like overkill to me.

26 May 2012 01:34 PM
Reply
RoyBatty     
BlippityBleep: in another few years they'll be on to taxing fatties, and i can't wait to vote the shiat out of upping taxes for fatassery causing habits.

First they came for the cigarette smokes,
and I didn't speak out because I didn't smoke cigarettes,

Then they came for the fatasseries
and I didn't speak out because my mouf was stuffed with donuts.

26 May 2012 01:36 PM
Reply
Trance750    [TotalFark]  
bim1154: SpikeStrip: one dollar cheetos tax coming soon.

And if it hasn't gone through yet, soft drinks too. I think they may have taxed bottled water, but can't remember.


I believe California is implementing (if they have not already) a tax on bottled drinks that are in 'non-decomposable containers'

26 May 2012 01:37 PM
Reply
iron_city_ap     
The stupid, it burns. Raise the tax by $1/pack and budget the money based on current sales. The increase cost makes more people quit. Medicaid is underfunded. Raise the tax by $1/pack.....

Also, I have a house for sale cheap by Illinois standards just off of Lake Michigan in Indiana about an hour drive outside of downtown with hourly train service as well. Open containers are legal on the beach there, just no glass. E-mail in profile. Its been on the market for about 18 months and paying 2 mortgages is getting old.... sorry if I shouldn't have posted that....

26 May 2012 01:37 PM
Reply
BlippityBleep     
RoyBatty: BlippityBleep: in another few years they'll be on to taxing fatties, and i can't wait to vote the shiat out of upping taxes for fatassery causing habits.

First they came for the cigarette smokes,
and I didn't speak out because I didn't smoke cigarettes,

Then they came for the fatasseries
and I didn't speak out because my mouf was stuffed with donuts.


but seriously, fark living how the government tells you to live. the stupid cattle farking population is disgustingly complacent with this shiat.

26 May 2012 01:38 PM
Reply
italie    [TotalFark]  
How is this spiffy?

They are short 2.7 BILLION in funding, and this generates $800 million....at least until the next batch of mass-quitters over the price increase happens. They've already cut 1.6 billion in funding. This is also just ~future~ budgeting. Go ahead and ask them how far they are in the hole already over owed money to various social services.


//why did I come back to this state....

26 May 2012 01:40 PM
Reply
Runed     
aevert: DeathByGeekSquad: Wisconsin and Indiana will see an uptick in business....

Seriously. The borders for those states are an hour or less from Illinois' largest population center (in good traffic).


Yeah, About that...

http://www.tobaccofreekids.org/resear ch/factsheets/pdf/0097.pdf

26 May 2012 01:41 PM
Reply
italie    [TotalFark]  
RibbyK: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

That's about half the rate for a new car in California. Everytime I visit Chicago I think "what crappy roads", then I remember this story: Link

CSB I worked with Joey Palumbo on highways 47 & 176 many moons ago, nice guy but obviously following in his father's footsteps.



Known as "Orange Crush" now. Apparently the Palumbo name has taken a bit of a hit....

26 May 2012 01:43 PM
Reply
RibbyK     
italie: //why did I come back to this state....

A few years ago, I too tried "coming back" home to Schaumburg, tried it for 12 months. Silly roads, long, dark winter, Mayor Daily, Obama. Get back out, quick!

26 May 2012 01:46 PM
Reply
FuturePastNow     
rfronk: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

My tags are $300 this month here in Kansas. $220 for a 6 year old vehicle and $80 for a 15 year old vehicle.


I'm a tax preparer, I had a client with income in Illinois and Missouri get frothing mad about our state income tax going up from 3% to 5%. When I pointed out his MO tax rate was 6% he kind of deflated.

People in Illinois complain about everything, but most of it is more expensive elsewhere.

More tax on cigarettes? Good. Buncha whiners.

26 May 2012 01:53 PM
Reply
demonfaerie     
Wisconsin did something like that with Badgercare, but then Walker cut the budget of Badgercare, and not a lot less people can be on it now.

26 May 2012 01:53 PM
Reply
kidsizedcoffin     
So another tax that disportionately affects the poor?

26 May 2012 01:55 PM
Reply
RibbyK     
demonfaerie: Wisconsin did something like that with Badgercare, but then Walker cut the budget of Badgercare, and now a lot less people can be on it now.

Yep, Socialism works great--until you run out of somebody else's money.

26 May 2012 01:55 PM
Reply
MFAWG     
Pretty good black market springing up in Washington State, which has the highest cigarette taxes in the nation.

OTOH, it's harder to get black market cigarettes than black market weed, so we've got that going for us, which is nice.

26 May 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
jim32rr    [TotalFark]  
FuturePastNow: rfronk: bim1154: And they are talking about adding another 2 dollars to license plate renewal bringing it up to $101. I swear, this fu(king state is a bottomless pit of spending. (and corruption).

My tags are $300 this month here in Kansas. $220 for a 6 year old vehicle and $80 for a 15 year old vehicle.

I'm a tax preparer, I had a client with income in Illinois and Missouri get frothing mad about our state income tax going up from 3% to 5%. When I pointed out his MO tax rate was 6% he kind of deflated.

People in Illinois complain about everything, but most of it is more expensive elsewhere.

More tax on cigarettes? Good. Buncha whiners.


Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn here on my Fark, no way.

26 May 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
jclaggett     
Reading this while enjoying a nice vanilla flavored nicotine fluid in an eGo-C. Yesterday was 3 weeks of not smoking.

26 May 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
RoyFokker'sGhost    [TotalFark]  
BronyMedic: Donnchadha: Keep government out of my Medicaid!

Considering a huge burdon on Medicaid and Medicare is caused by elderly smokers with COPD, and the majority of those cases are caused by life-long cigarette use, I'm ok with this.


But, there's 2 obvious problems to this plan that States with cigarette taxes have found out the hard way

1) When has any State spent 'allocated' funds the way they're supposed to? A good chunk (if not a majority) of that $1/pack will go to projects that have absolutely nothing to do with Medicaid, but benefit state politicians via pork and pet projects. Even if it's written into the law that 100% of these funds *must* go to Medicaid, politicians will decrease the amount of funding Medicaid gets from other sources, since it now has a 'dedicated' revenue stream.

2) Yes, over the long term the number of smokers will decrease if you add more taxes to cigarettes. Which does lower the need to pay for their long-term health care through Medicaid. Eventually though, you will get to a point where having less people buying the taxed product will harm your budget. Sure, Medicaid will require less funds, theoretically keeping pace with the decrease in tax revenue, but if you see Point #1, the taxes will be going to support more than just Medicaid. And politicians will be loathe to give up funding for their own pet projects that benefit them. So, the funding for other stuff will remain the same, having grown over the years by dipping into the extra tax source, and the budget for social programs (Medicaid, education, social services) will be slashed to cover up the new shortfall.

Now, that's not to say the cigarette tax won't work, just that it's a spiraling path that can hurt the very programs it's been enacted to help if left unchecked and unmonitored. California has passed the tipping point in terms of cigarette taxes and smoking bans and is starting to work to repeal some of the taxes and restrictions in order to bring the revenue back.

26 May 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
Farty McPooPants     
I love when we prove the Founding Fathers right.

/They prohibited direct taxes.

no longer empty and frantic
like a cat
tied to a stick
that's driven into
frozen winter shiat (the ability to laugh at weakness)
calm
fitter
healthier and more productive
a pig
in a cage
on antibiotics

26 May 2012 01:58 PM
Reply
RibbyK     
kidsizedcoffin: So another tax that disportionately affects the poor?

Yes, cuz they can't use food stamps to buy smokes.

26 May 2012 01:59 PM
Reply
Showing 1-50 of 195 comments
Refresh Page 2
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Main

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party