Report This Ad (full site)
Fark.com

Back To Politics
   Reagan adviser to GOP: You can believe raising taxes is always bad for the economy, but only if you can explain the Clinton boom

06 Aug 2012 01:35 PM   |   3715 clicks   |   The New York Times
Add Comment
Showing 1-50 of 303 comments
Refresh Page 2
Aarontology    [TotalFark]  
Or those tax increases Reagan signed.

06 Aug 2012 09:52 AM
Reply
Angry Drunk Bureaucrat    [TotalFark]  
The Clinton boom was explained by the stock market anticipating a Bush presidency.

06 Aug 2012 10:01 AM
Reply
CPT Ethanolic    [TotalFark]  
Bruce Bartlett and Barry Ritholtz are both essential daily reads for anyone into politics or economics. Brilliant people.

06 Aug 2012 10:04 AM
Reply
propasaurus    [TotalFark]  
The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

06 Aug 2012 10:28 AM
Reply
MaudlinMutantMollusk    [TotalFark]  
propasaurus: The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

Ok... but who's onshmer?

06 Aug 2012 10:36 AM
Reply
cman    [TotalFark]  
Same reason why the economy rocked during the industrial revolution. The Internet/computer (or digital) revolution brought upon a time of significant investing in new technologies. While a lot of it was real growth, most of it was just a bubble

06 Aug 2012 10:40 AM
Reply
propasaurus    [TotalFark]  
MaudlinMutantMollusk: propasaurus: The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer CONSUMER confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

Ok... but who's onshmer?


Bah.

06 Aug 2012 10:51 AM
Reply
DjangoStonereaver    [TotalFark]  
propasaurus: The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

Wow.

I'm amazed that you have enough brainpower to even breath on your own.

06 Aug 2012 12:39 PM
Reply
This About That    [TotalFark]  
Wouldn't it all depend upon what the gummint did with the tax revenue?

06 Aug 2012 12:57 PM
Reply
kronicfeld    [TotalFark]  
DjangoStonereaver: I'm amazed that you have enough brainpower to even breath on your own.

I'm amazed how immune everyone on these goddamn boards are to sarcasm.

06 Aug 2012 12:59 PM
Reply
vernonFL    [TotalFark]  
I think the so called "Clinton boom" was actually caused by the end of the cold war and the beginnings of the internet age.

06 Aug 2012 01:07 PM
Reply
ricewater_stool    [TotalFark]  
Tax rates were even higher in the 1950s and that was possibly the most prosperous time in our country's history. It also allowed us to build the entire interstate highway system and start the space program.

06 Aug 2012 01:17 PM
Reply
DjangoStonereaver    [TotalFark]  
ricewater_stool: Tax rates were even higher in the 1950s and that was possibly the most prosperous time in our country's history. It also allowed us to build the entire interstate highway system and start the space program.

You know who else had an interstate highway system and the start of a space program?

06 Aug 2012 01:18 PM
Reply
dittybopper    [TotalFark]  
cman: Same reason why the economy rocked during the industrial revolution. The Internet/computer (or digital) revolution brought upon a time of significant investing in new technologies. While a lot of it was real growth, most of it was just a bubble

This. And that bubble popped before Clinton left office.

/Was laid off in the post-Y2K programmer glut.

06 Aug 2012 01:36 PM
Reply
Duke Phillips' Singing Bears     
DjangoStonereaver: propasaurus: The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

Wow.

I'm amazed that you have enough brainpower to even breath on your own.


The greatest tragedy of the troll infection on Fark is the ongoing inability of most people on these boards to recognize a good, old-fashioned joke. Happens to me, too.

06 Aug 2012 01:38 PM
Reply
SN1987a goes boom     
kronicfeld: DjangoStonereaver: I'm amazed that you have enough brainpower to even breath on your own.

I'm amazed how immune everyone on these goddamn boards are to sarcasm.


The sad thing is the original comment could easily pass as a deeply held belief of the Tea Party.

06 Aug 2012 01:40 PM
Reply
Citrate1007     
The Tea Party needs to learn how our government, economy, and freedom works before they destroy our country.

06 Aug 2012 01:40 PM
Reply
HotWingConspiracy     
B...blowjobs? Is the answer blowjobs?

06 Aug 2012 01:40 PM
Reply
Jackson Herring    [TotalFark]  
Duke Phillips' Singing Bears: The greatest tragedy of the troll infection on Fark is the ongoing inability of most people on these boards to recognize a good, old-fashioned joke. Happens to me, too.

it helps to have more than a five-second memory of people's usernames

06 Aug 2012 01:41 PM
Reply
theknuckler_33    [TotalFark]  
Raising taxes is always bad for the economy as it takes money out of consumers hands. However, if the economy is good, it can probably absorb a modest tax increase assuming the additional revenue is used to bring the financial house back in order. This is usually the problem.

06 Aug 2012 01:41 PM
Reply
SeismicJizzer     
Bartlett should save his breath, you can't convince the inbred base that the charlatans who are running their party have been lying to them for decades.

Reality has a liberal bias, they don't have the need to live in reality.

06 Aug 2012 01:42 PM
Reply
Zeno-25     
i.imgur.com

06 Aug 2012 01:42 PM
Reply
imontheinternet    [TotalFark]  
... but tax cuts are what economies crave.

06 Aug 2012 01:44 PM
Reply
theorellior     
Well, Clinton never read Hayek or Mises, so Mittens is automatically president and Obama has to reenact "The Fountainhead" with finger puppets.

06 Aug 2012 01:44 PM
Reply
Citrate1007     
Zeno-25: [i.imgur.com image 720x511]

So close tax loopholes for corporations and offshore accounting?

06 Aug 2012 01:45 PM
Reply
sugardave     
Zeno-25: [i.imgur.com image 720x511]

The latter, right?

06 Aug 2012 01:45 PM
Reply
Jubeebee    [TotalFark]  
HotWingConspiracy: B...blowjobs? Is the answer blowjobs?

I really hope the answer is blowjobs.

06 Aug 2012 01:45 PM
Reply
Skyrmion     
Clearly, the boom came from Clinton's middle-class tax cut. The higher taxes on the rich must have just stopped the boom from being even bigger.

06 Aug 2012 01:45 PM
Reply
zarberg     
Duke Phillips' Singing Bears: The greatest tragedy of the troll infection on Fark is the ongoing inability of most people on these boards to recognize a good, old-fashioned joke. Happens to me, too.

Don't be too mad at Django, he played a dwarf in D&D.

That being said, FARK really needs a sarcasm font modifier.

06 Aug 2012 01:46 PM
Reply
Wyalt Derp     
"This requires Republicans to try to rewrite the economic history of that decade."


Challenge accepted.

(retroactively)

06 Aug 2012 01:47 PM
Reply
DirkValentine     
Let me guess :

B/c of the previous 2 Republican administration?

06 Aug 2012 01:48 PM
Reply
natazha     
kronicfeld: DjangoStonereaver: I'm amazed that you have enough brainpower to even breath on your own.

I'm amazed how immune everyone on these goddamn boards are to sarcasm.


Truthiness is stronger than sarcasm. I'm reminded of my introduction to Landover Baptist Church's site. Having been raised in the mid-West, I thought it was a real church. And somewhat moderate at that.

06 Aug 2012 01:49 PM
Reply
DjangoStonereaver    [TotalFark]  
zarberg: Duke Phillips' Singing Bears: The greatest tragedy of the troll infection on Fark is the ongoing inability of most people on these boards to recognize a good, old-fashioned joke. Happens to me, too.

Don't be too mad at Django, he played a dwarf in D&D.


A dwarven sorcerer, which was the closest thing I could think of to a damn hippie among dwarven
kind.

With a thing for elf chicks.

That being said, FARK really needs a sarcasm font modifier.

I forgot to apply Poe's law directly to my forehead.

06 Aug 2012 01:49 PM
Reply
MyRandomName     
One day liberals will learn that, while a small factor, tax rates and who the president is are not primary factors in economic expansions. One day.

06 Aug 2012 01:49 PM
Reply
Jodeo     
The "Clinton Boom" explained... ...sorta

1. The end/wrap-up of the Savings and Loan Bail-out at the end of the 1980s in the 1990s.
2. Increased IT spending in anticipation of the Y2Kpocalypse.
3. The Dot-Com boom.
4. China promoted to most favored nation trade status.
...among other factors.

* Bush 1 was fired for bringing on the largest tax increase in history: $500 Billion.
* The dems in Congress were fired for doing it again: Another $500 Billion increase (net $1 Trillion roughly).
* The net effect of Bush 2's tax cuts was about reducing those tax increases by one-third, or $350 Billion.

The economy grew despite the tax increases because of the opportunities that existed (especially Y2K and the internet). Those fizzled going into 2001. W's cuts stimulated economic growth until the housing crisis blew up the economy (a natural market correction to the unintended consequences of government action coupled with horrific investment strategies to mask high-risk investments).

Hey, if the Clinton years were so great, why not go back to the spending levels of the latter 1990s as well?

The solution is to have a flexible tax rate that can be adjusted (up or down, modestly) as we can with interest rates. Implement gradual increases as the economy grows and decreases as the economy stabelizes or slows. The balanced budgets of the 1990s was due to fiscal restraint, sure, but also because these two tax increases were still in effect. W's tax cuts helped, but RIGHT NOW we need to overhaul the tax code.

Unfortunately, we are spending our nation out of existence (bi-partisan blame for all). I hear Costa Rica's nice.


Oh, wait - shoot. This is a Fark Politics thread: WHY DO I DO THIS TO MYSELF???

06 Aug 2012 01:50 PM
Reply
theorellior     
cman: Same reason why the economy rocked during the industrial revolution. The Internet/computer (or digital) revolution brought upon a time of significant investing in new technologies. While a lot of it was real growth, most of it was just a bubble

But higher taxes are supposed to keep the Job Creators from creating jobs? How did they ever managed to create a boom while shackled under all that tax burden?

I know, maybe it's because we're still waaaaaaaay to the left of the optimum of the Laffer Curve. That is, if you believe in the validity of the Laffer Curve, which I'm assuming you do, because most of the arguments about lowering taxes ultimately come from that little bit of economic wankery.

06 Aug 2012 01:50 PM
Reply
thisone     
zarberg:

That being said, FARK really needs a sarcasm font modifier.


it's depressing cause it's true.Maybe if we took over the underused superscript option? Because, you know, it's Super!

06 Aug 2012 01:51 PM
Reply
lennavan     
cman: Same reason why the economy rocked during the industrial revolution. The Internet/computer (or digital) revolution brought upon a time of significant investing in new technologies. While a lot of it was real growth, most of it was just a bubble

A lot of real growth came from the internet/computer revolution. What made the internet/computer revolution possible? Where did it arise from?

Biotechnology is another enormous rapidly growing field. What made that possible?

upload.wikimedia.org

The NSF. Also known as socialism.

06 Aug 2012 01:51 PM
Reply
Lost Thought 00    [TotalFark]  
The Bush Boom, followed by the Clinton Recession, followed by the Bush Boom, followed by the Obama Recession

06 Aug 2012 01:51 PM
Reply
theorellior     
Jodeo: W's tax cuts helped

Helped what? Put us in the mess we're in now?

Jodeo: Implement gradual increases as the economy grows and decreases as the economy stabelizes or slows.

Whoa, whoa, whoa, back the fark up. It sounds like you're talking... KEYNSIAN!

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSS!!!!

06 Aug 2012 01:52 PM
Reply
regindyn     
propasaurus: The Clinton boom was the result of GHW Bush's policies and the Gingrich-led Congress keeping the tax & spend Clintonite Democrats in check. The recession during W's administration was a result of the Clinton high taxes taking effect. Just like 9/11 was a failure of Clinton's foreign policy and being soft on terrorism. Any upswing we've seen in the last 3+ years has been the residual effects of W's policies of fiscal responsibility and the last 2 years of a Republican House. Now we're seeing onshmer confidence springing back because Americans are anticipating a Romney presidency.

I like it.

06 Aug 2012 01:53 PM
Reply
zarberg     
DjangoStonereaver: A dwarven sorcerer, which was the closest thing I could think of to a damn hippie among dwarven
kind.

With a thing for elf chicks.


Who used a horn of fog in the middle of a combat which obscured my view of being able to get 75% of the bad guys in a fireball!

06 Aug 2012 01:54 PM
Reply
lennavan     
Jodeo: Oh, wait - shoot. This is a Fark Politics thread: WHY DO I DO THIS TO MYSELF???

The important thing is you have found a way to position yourself superior to anyone who replies to you.

06 Aug 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
Snarcoleptic_Hoosier    [TotalFark]  
But liberals bad, subby! Liberals bad!

/I like how "tax and spend" is a considered a negative term

06 Aug 2012 01:57 PM
Reply
hammettman     
Lost Thought 00: The Bush Boom, followed by the Clinton Recession, followed by the Bush Boom, followed by the Obama Recession

In my house, the Bush Boom is always followed by a cigarette.

06 Aug 2012 01:58 PM
Reply
theorellior     
zarberg: DjangoStonereaver: A dwarven sorcerer, which was the closest thing I could think of to a damn hippie among dwarven
kind.

With a thing for elf chicks.

Who used a horn of fog in the middle of a combat which obscured my view of being able to get 75% of the bad guys in a fireball!


I SHOOT THE GAZEBO WITH MY BOW.

06 Aug 2012 01:59 PM
Reply
Doogles4221     
zarberg: DjangoStonereaver: A dwarven sorcerer, which was the closest thing I could think of to a damn hippie among dwarven
kind.

With a thing for elf chicks.

Who used a horn of fog in the middle of a combat which obscured my view of being able to get 75% of the bad guys in a fireball!


You should have used the spell of Tax Cuts, (3rd level, standard action) then those bad guys would start a business and you could have used the ecomomic prosperity to solve all the world's problems.

06 Aug 2012 01:59 PM
Reply
RolandGunner     
Deregulation of the communications industry in the 80s lead to an explosion in IT technology that created the internet and computing technology boom of the 90s in spite of higher taxes.

There, explained it in one sentence.

06 Aug 2012 02:00 PM
Reply
Mikey1969     
According to the Congressional Budget Office, the federal budget deficit fell every year of the Clinton administration, from $290 billion in 1992 to $255 billion in 1993, $203 billion in 1994, $164 billion in 1995, $107 billion in 1996, and $22 billion in 1997. In 1998, there was a budget surplus of $69 billion, which rose to $126 billion in 1999 and $236 billion in 2000 before it was dissipated by huge tax cuts during the George W. Bush administration.

THAT is the most important part of the entire article, right there. There's a lot of good stuff, but too many forget about the surplus Clinton left behind when they factor in the current deficit into bitaching about Obama. Not only did Bush add trillions to the debt, he wiped away a $200 BILLION durplus on top of it.

06 Aug 2012 02:01 PM
Reply
Teufelaffe    [TotalFark]  
You guys have it all wrong. This is what it looks like just before you receive the "Clinton Boom."

2.bp.blogspot.com

06 Aug 2012 02:02 PM
Reply
Showing 1-50 of 303 comments
Refresh Page 2
This thread is closed to new comments.


Back To Politics

More Headlines:
Main | Sports | Business | Geek | Entertainment | Politics | Video | FarkUs | Contests | Fark Party